Tag: SK Nair

  • Madras High Court verdict on television rights Thursday

    Madras High Court verdict on television rights Thursday

    NEW DELHI: The cricket saga lurches on from one twist to another.

    Even as the Madras High Court today said it would deliver tomorrow interim orders on telecasting arrangements for the upcoming India-Pakistan cricket matches, ESPN Star Sports matched Zee Telefilms offer to produce, telecast and share the revenues with the Indian cricket board for the matches, while sharing a feed with the pubcaster Doordarshan.

    According to a report filed from Chennai by the Press Trust of India, reserving orders on a writ petition filed by Zee Telefilms challenging the Indian cricket boards decision cancelling the tender process, Justice KP Sivasubramanian said he would deliver orders tomorrow on live telecast of one-day as well as
    Test matches between the two sides.

    The judge will deliver orders on the main petition later.

    Meanwhile, in a letter to the Board of Control for cricket in India (BCCI), ESPN Star Sports MD Rik Dovey has said,In the event that the foregoing suggestion is acceptable to the BCCI, we suggest ESS and the BCCI jointly approach the honourable court and recommend that it authorises the implementation of this solution.

    Zee Telefilms had made a similar offer on telecasting the matches through a submission in the high court yesterday. However, pubcaster Prasar Bharati has rejected the “proposals” put forth by Zee and ESS and asserted that it would manage the production of the event on its own.

    Prasar Bharati today admitted that the BCCI had made it an offer to produce and market the India-Pakistan cricket matches that could be telecast by Doordarshan on mutually agreed commercial terms.

    Pointing out that such a scenario was acceptable to Prasar Bharati, which manages DD, its CEO KS Sarma said, “The BCCI offer is fine as far as the cricket board pays a minimum guarantee fee for the matches.”

    The revenue, as per the BCCI offer, was to be shared in the ratio of 70:30 in favour of the cricket board.

    Essel Group vice-president (corporate brand development) Ashish Kaul states, “It is strange that it took ESPN Star Sports so long to make an offer to BCCI and that too almost similar to our offer. Now it is quite apparent that these people are only interested in exploiting Indian cricket. Had they been so well intentioned and concerned about the welfare of cricket then they should have made an offer a long time ago”

    Despite repeated attempts, BCCI chief RS Mahendra could not be contacted for comments.

    The ESS letter to BCCI states that the media company would provide production of international standards and “at a minimum as required by the BCCI’s invitation to tender of 7 August last.” However, in return, ESS wants that it would get the rights to telecast the Indian-Pakistan cricket matches, while sharing the feed with DD on terms acceptable to the cricket board.

    ESS will deposit the advertising revenues which it receives following deduction of applicable agency commission, any cost incurred and fees payable to Prasar Bharati in relation to its telecast, any applicable taxes and mutually agreed production cost with the BCCI, Dovey has a conveyed to the BCCI
    secretary SK Nair.

    Yesterday, Zee had said that it is completely ready and willing, pending the final decision in the writ petition, to cover and telecast the forthcoming India vs Pakistan Cricket match series to be played in India.

    ZTL would do this entirely at its risks and costs and without any
    equity in its favour.

    The company had further said that it should deposit the entire advertisement revenue collected thereof (net of agency commission) both on its channel as well as Doordarshan, with the BCCI.

    ZTL will only require to be paid production costs as mutually agreed as well as any telecast fee, which ZTL would be required to pay to Prasar Bharati. ZTL shall also deposit with BCCI the entire amount which it may collect from international syndication sales without deducting our sales commission there from (BCCI had paid 15 per cent commission for the last series for international syndication sales),Zee had said.

  • Let’s resolve cricket telecast issue: Zee to BCCI

    Let’s resolve cricket telecast issue: Zee to BCCI

    NEW DELHI: India’s largest vertically-integrated media company Zee Telefilms has extended an olive branch to the Indian cricket board with an aim to resolve the deadlocked cricket telecast issue.

    In a letter, written by Zee Tele CMD Subhash Chandra to the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) president Ranbir Singh Mahendra, Zee has asked the Board to give primacy to Indian cricket, while seeking to resolve the matter.

    Now that a new team has taken over, we were wanting to explore the possibility of a reasonable resolution of the issue of telecast of TV rights,Chandra has written in the letter,dated 1 February.

    This letter, now in the possession of Indiantelevision.com, clearly states that Zee is willing to put the unpleasantness of the past behind and move on to fulfilling its commitment to Indian cricket as stressed in the post-bidding period.

    Pointing out that Zee has grave apprehensions over the conduct of the past officials of the BCCI, which were subject matter of petitions in Indian courts, Chandra has said that his company is willing to explore solutions consistent with our legitimate rights and expectations.

    The communication from Chandra to Mahendra, however, makes it clear that things might get messy if people, who had assisted Zee with funds (for the possible acquisition of the telecast rights that had emboldened Zee to quote a price of $ 308 million), made counter claims on the media company.

    We are also conscious of possible claims from those who assisted us with funds and irrespective of the results of the present case,Chandra hammers in a point, adding,If claims are made against us,it would further complicate matters between the Board and us.

    The letter goes on to add, giving the tale a truly soap opera and swadeshi twist,We are sure that there being no truly other competing Indian channel in the fray (other than Indian pubcaster Doordarshan), there is no legal impediment in the Board arriving at some reasonable arrangement with us.

    In its wisdom, the BCCI did not reply to Chandras letter, subsequent to which another letter from Zee followed 15 days later. This too has drawn a blank from the BCCI that, anyway, met in the Capital earlier this week to discuss various matters related to the up and coming tour of Pakistan to India.

    BCCIs failure to respond to these letters raises the question as to why the Indian cricket board is not acknowledging the letter when the other side is expressing willingness to discuss the issue and settle it amicably.

    Efforts made by indiantelevision.com to elicit a response from the BCCI on the Chandra letter drew a blank.

    To do a quick recap of the cricket telecast saga, last year after the bids for the rights opened, and after a lot of backroom drama, Zee Telefilms emerged the highest contender with a revised quote of $ 308 million, closely followed by ESPN Star Sports. BCCI announced its decision to award the rights till 2007 to Zee when legal doors were knocked by various parties.

    After the Supreme Court recently refusing to accept the BCCI as a ‘State under Article 12 of the Indian Constitution, Zee moved the Madras high court against the BCCI, which had cancelled the bids, claiming breach of fundamental rights under Article 226 of the Constitution.

    The petition was filed on 7 February in the Madras HC.At the hearing on 9 February the judge passed an “unconditional” interim order “restraining BCCI from negotiating or getting into any kind of contract with anyone regarding the award of telecast rights till further notice.”

    The case came up for hearing on 17 February and the argument will continue on 21 February. Meanwhile, the BCCI has admitted that it has incurred a loss of Rs 1,500 million so far due to the telecast rights not having been awarded far in a proper way. In a letter to Niranjan Shah, Secretary of Saurashtra Cricket Association, BCCI secretary SK Nair admitted that the on-going impasse over the telecast issue has resulted in a loss to the Board.

    Nair, in his letter, stated that Doordarshan would be paying Rs. 1 billion for the terrestrial rights of the matches against Australia and South Africa and another Rs 300 million is expected from the sale of overseas rights.

    “Therefore, if we assume that Rs 2,75 crore (Rs 2,750 million) would have come from these two series if the four-year deal was through, the ad hoc arrangement for the Australia and South Africa series had fetched Rs 125 crore (Rs 1,250 million) and, therefore, the total loss was say Rs 150 crore (Rs 1,500 million),” Nair has informed Shah.

    As the telecast rights issue returns, like Banquos ghost, to haunt everybody, including the Indian public, before a cricket series begins, it seems like time to set things in order once and for all.

  • BCCI tender panel meeting inconclusive on India rights

    BCCI tender panel meeting inconclusive on India rights

    MUMBAI: The India telecast rights intrigue continues. In what has come as no surprise to many in the industry, the crucial meeting of the Tender Committee of the Board for Cricket Control in India (BCCI), which took place in Chennai this morning, failed to come to any conclusions as to which party — Zee Telefilms or ESPN Star Sports — was the rightful claimant of the most prized possession on Indian television today.

    Cricket board president Jagmohan Dalmiya and other senior office bearers of the BCCI, including Jyothi Bajpayee, Kishore Rungta and Tamil Nadu Cricket Association president N Srinivasan are among the senior members in this committee. However, BCCI secretary SK Nair, who is also in this panel, is away in England attending a meeting of the ICC, agency reports have said.

    What remains to be seen is whether the BCCI’s Marketing Committee meeting scheduled for tomorrow, at which the rights winner was earlier expected to be announced, throws up anything more conclusive. From this vantage, something definitive from the Indian cricket board, which is a divided house on the telecast rights issue, looks increasingly uncertain. This committee includes Dalmiya and former BCCI president AC Muthiah, among others.

    While Zee Telefilms has offered $260 million, ESPN STAR Sports (ESS) has come up with an offer of $230 million to the BCCI for four years. SET Max, Prasar Bharati and Ten Sports have also put in their offers. But they were way behind the two main contenders.

    The fight between Zee and ESS is for the live television and radio broadcast rights for international matches to be played in India for the next four years