Category: TDSAT

  • TDSAT directs Hathway to not disconnect signals of Siddhi Vinayak Cable Ops Association members

    TDSAT directs Hathway to not disconnect signals of Siddhi Vinayak Cable Ops Association members

    NEW DELHI: The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) has directed Hathway Cable & Datacom to not disconnect the supply of signals to any of the 16 cable operators who are part of the Siddhi Vinayak Cable Operators Association.

     

    Chairman Justice Aftab Alam and members Kuldip Singh and B B Srivastava also directed the MSO and the Association to resolve their problems through mediation and asked them to appear before the Mediation Centre.

     

    Hathway counsel J K Mehta told the Tribunal that his client was equally aggrieved by non-payment of regular monthly subscription fees by the members of the petitioner association. Mehta also stated that the cable operators are liable to make payment @ Rs 115 per STB (exclusive of taxes) prior to packaging.

     

    The Tribunal said the cable operators in turn will continue to make payment of the monthly subscription fees on the basis of the last payment made by them respectively.

     

    The Mediation Centre will try to resolve the disputes between the parties expeditiously and without any unnecessary loss of time, the bench said.

  • TDSAT directs NSTPL to restore signals of cable network on receipt of payments

    TDSAT directs NSTPL to restore signals of cable network on receipt of payments

    NEW DELHI: The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) has asked Headend in the Sky (HITS) operator Noida Software Technology Park Ltd (NSTPL) to not disconnect signals to Guru Kripa Cable Network subject to the petitioner making certain payments.

     

    Member Kuldip Singh sitting in the vacation bench admitted the petition by the Cable Network.

     

    The Tribunal has directed payment of Rs 60,000 within three weeks from today and another payment of Rs 55,000 within three weeks thereafter.

     

    While the cable network admits dues of Rs 1,13,956, its counsel told the Tribunal that the amount needs to be reconciled since it had made some excess payment earlier.

     

    The Tribunal directed that NSTPL will file its reply within four weeks and rejoinder if any will be filed within two weeks of receipt of the reply.

     

    The matter will now go before the Registrar on 12 August for getting the pleadings completed, framing of issues and if the parties concur, taking evidences etc.

     

    Apart from the payment of the dues, Guru Kripa Cable Network will continue to make payment of the monthly subscription fees on the basis of invoices raised by the NSTPL.

     

     The payments will be without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties.

     

    The cable network told the Tribunal that some of their Set Top Boxes have been deactivated by NSTPL and they are not receiving all the channels on the other activated STBs. However, NSTPL counsel Joby Varghese made a categorical statement that all the channels are being given for the activated STBs. However, some STBs for which CAFs have not been submitted by the cable network have been disconnected.   

     

    Varghese stated that these STBs will be activated immediately but the petitioner must supply CAFs for the same, as required by the regulation.

     

    Cable network counsel Mayank Kshirasagar stated that the CAFs will be supplied within two weeks from today.

     

    The Tribunal said its order should not come in the way of the parties meeting to reconcile their accounts. The balance dues, found if any, shall be cleared by the network.

  • TDSAT asks BECIL to include Sun Distribution issues in Digicable audit

    TDSAT asks BECIL to include Sun Distribution issues in Digicable audit

    NEW DELHI: The Broadcast Engineering Consultants (India) Ltd, which had earlier been directed by the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) to conduct an audit of Digicable Network in a case filed against IndiaCast, has now been asked to include issues relating to Sun Distribution Services in its audit.

     

    Earlier on 26 May, Sun had been denied permission to carry out an audit of Digicable on an objection raised by Digicable.

     

    However, in a separate order on 29 May, TDSAT had directed BECIL to carry out an audit in a case filed by Digicable against IndiaCast.

     

    The order by TDSAT chairman Aftab Alam and member Kuldip Singh today came on a miscellaneous application by Sun that BECIL may also address the apprehensions and suspicions of the Sun Distribution as regards the technical system of Digicable Network.

     

    The Tribunal said it found the request reasonable and directed that it would be open to having Sun Distribution Services’ representative present at the time of the audit of the Digicable’s system by BECIL.

     

    In case BECIL withholds the audit on the ground that it may damage the systems of Digicable Network, it would ensure that the data from the Subscriber Management System systems concerning Sun Distribution also may not be manipulated to give any false reports in future.

     

    On 26 May, Digicable had urged TDSAT not to allow Sun to undertake its audit on 24 July on the ground that the respondent was currently engaged in the replacement of its SMS.

     

    In the order of 29 May, BECIL had been asked to check and confirm whether Digicable’s Conditional Access System (CAS) and Subscriber Management System at its different headends are properly integrated and correctly and truly reflect its subscriber base. BECIL had also been asked to record the number of subscribers at the different DAS head-ends. BECIL was asked to conduct the technical audit of Digicable’s local areas with a view to find out whether there are any parallel systems running.

     

    Meanwhile in another case, Sun Distribution was asked not to disconnect the signals to Subodhaya Communications Pvt. Ltd. provided Subodhaya made payment of the amount mentioned in the notice as dues (Rs 8,98,544) within 10 days from today.

     

    Apart from the payment of dues, the petitioner shall continue to make payment of the monthly subscription fees on the basis of invoices raised by the respondent.

     

    Listing the matter for 14 July, the vacation bench of TDSAT said the payments would be without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties.

  • Star India directed to restore Vishal Cables’ signals subject to Rs 15 lakh payment

    Star India directed to restore Vishal Cables’ signals subject to Rs 15 lakh payment

    NEW DELHI: Star India was today directed by the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) to restore signals to Vishal Cable Network provided the latter makes an on account payment of Rs 15 lakh to the company in three equal fortnightly installments.

     

    TDSAT has directed Vishal Cable Network to pay the first installment of Rs 5 lakh in the course of the day and another sum of Rs 5 lakh by 24 June and the third installment for the same amount by 9 July.

     

    The payment “shall be on account and without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties.”

     

    The matter will come up on 24 July for further directions.

     

    In the meanwhile, the parties are directed to have reconciliation of accounts to ascertain the exact dues against the petitioner.

     

    The vacation bench of TSDAT chairman Aftab Alam and member B B Srivastava said that during the pendency of this petition, Vishal Cable will continue to make payments of the monthly subscription fees on the basis of invoices raised by Star India.

     

    In case of default in payment of the installments and / or monthly subscription fees as per the invoices of Star India, it will be open to it to disconnect the supply of its signals without any further orders from the Tribunal.

     

    Star India was directed to file the reply within four weeks from today; and rejoinder, if any, may be filed within two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of the reply.  

    The petition was filed against the disconnection notice of 12 May issued under Clause 6.1 of the 2012 interconnect regulation. In pursuance of the notice, Star India has disconnected the supply of its signals to the petitioner on 5 June.

     

    The disconnection notice is based on the grounds of non-submission of SMS reports, non-payment of license fees and non-cooperation in audit. According to the notice, the dues of license fee against the petitioner amount to Rs 13.2 lakh as on 31 March this year.

     

    Vishal Cable has been directed to give Star India SMS reports for the months of April and May 2015 within two days from today, i.e. 11 June. Star can commence the audit of the Vishal Cable’s technical system on 16 June and the Vishal will offer full cooperation in conduct of the audit.

  • TDSAT asks Taj TV to restore UCN Cable signals subject to dues payment

    TDSAT asks Taj TV to restore UCN Cable signals subject to dues payment

    NEW DELHI: The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) today directed Taj Television to restore signals to UCN Cable Network by tomorrow (10 June, 2015) provided the multi-satellite operator (MSO) pays to it a sum of Rs 1.5 crore within a week from today and another sum of Rs 1.5 crore within four weeks from the date of the first payment.

     

    The vacation bench of TDSAT chairman Aftab Alam and member B B Srivastava made it clear that this on account payment “shall be without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties.”

     

    This admitted petition was filed against the disconnection notices and according to the notices, Taj TV’s dues against UCN Cable for Digital Addressable System (DAS) and non-DAS areas amounts to Rs 4.4 crore as on 20 April, 2015. In pursuance of the notices, the respondent has disconnected the supply of its signals to the petitioner on 27 May, 2015.

     

    Apart from the aforesaid on account payment, UCN Cable will also pay Taj TV a monthly subscription fees as per the invoices raised by the respondent. In case of default in payment of the installments and / or monthly subscription fees as per the invoices of Taj TV, it will be open to it to disconnect the supply of its signals without any further orders from the Tribunal.

     

    The matter has been listed on 17 July for further directions. Meanwhile, Taj TV was asked to file its reply within three weeks and UCN Cable to file its rejoinder if any within two weeks of that.

  • TDSAT stays MSM Discovery’s disconnection orders against Meghbala

    TDSAT stays MSM Discovery’s disconnection orders against Meghbala

    NEW DELHI: The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) directed MSM Discovery Private Ltd not to give effect to its disconnection notices to Meghbala Cable and Broadband Services Pvt. Ltd. in Kolkata, Behrampur, Haldia and Bankura pending final orders of the Tribunal.

     

    The vacation bench of TDSAT chairman Aftab Alam listed the matter for 20 July, issuing notice to MSM Discovery to file its reply by 3 July and Mebhbala to file rejoinder thereto by 10 July.

     

    The Tribunal said MSM Discover will remove the OSDs running on the petitioner’s network provided the petitioner makes an on account payment of Rs 50 lakh to the MSM in two installments, the first installment of Rs 25 lakh payable by 15 June and the second installment of Rs 25 lakh by 30 June.

     

    It said the payment will be without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties and will abide by the final outcome of these petitions. 

  • Rajahmundry MSO to get signals of Taj TV & Maa TV; Eenadu & Sun signals on interim basis

    Rajahmundry MSO to get signals of Taj TV & Maa TV; Eenadu & Sun signals on interim basis

    NEW DELHI: The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) has directed Eenadu and Sun TV to enter into interim and provisional interconnect agreements to supply signals to multi system operator (MSO) Vaji Digital Network in Rajahmundry, which is not a Digital Addressable System (DAS) area.

     

    TDSAT chairman Aftab Alam and member Kuldip Singh said the agreement would be on a fixed monthly fee at the rate of 25 per cent of the aggregate amount of monthly subscription fee that they are receiving from their MSOs in Rajahmundry. 

     

    Eenadu has one MSO from which it receives Rs 7,48,225 (exclusive of taxes) as monthly subscription fee. Sun has two MSOs in Rajahmundry from whom it receives an aggregate of Rs 11,92,929 as the monthly subscription fee. 

     

    The provisional agreements with the petitioner will be at the rate of 25 per cent of the aforesaid amounts respectively. 

     

    The Tribunal made it clear that the interim agreements will be without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the parties and the amount fixed for the provisional agreement will abide by the final determination in these two petitions. The agreements, as directed, may be executed forthwith and not later than a week from today and supply of signals should commence immediately on that basis. 

     

    While giving the order, the Tribunal said it would give its final order on 22 July with regard to Eenadu and Sun.

     

    However, the Tribunal resolved the matters relating to Maa TV and Taj TV with the consent of both sides.

     

    A direction was given to MAA TV to execute an interconnect agreement with Vaji, the petitioner on a fixed fee of Rs 90,000 (exclusive of taxes) per month. The agreement may be executed forthwith and not later than a week from today and supply of signals should commence immediately on that basis. 

     

    Taj TV submitted that in Rajahmundry area the broadcaster was receiving Rs 6,95,975 as the monthly subscription fee for the Taj group of channels. Taj TV counsel Tejveer Bhatia said Taj was willing to give the signals of its channels to the petitioner on monthly subscription at the rate of 30 per cent of the subscription fee received by it from the other MSO for the first quarter, 35 per cent of that amount for the second quarter and 40 per cent of the amount for the third and fourth quarters. The offer was accepted by Vaji and so the petition was disposed with the direction to enter into an interconnect agreement in the aforesaid terms. The agreement may be executed forthwith and not later than a week from today and supply of signals should commence immediately on that basis.

     

    A new entrant in the field of broadcasting, MSO Vaji had sought to enter into agreements with the four broadcasters to get their signals. However, the broadcasters did not accept the Service Line Report whereby the petitioner gave the number of subscribers he had with him.

     

    The matter was first referred to the arbitration centre but could not be resolved.

     

    In another similar matter by Rudhrapur Cable Network against Star TV, the Tribunal appointed Vadivelu Deenadayalan as an Advocate Commissioner with the consent of the both the parties to carry out the survey of the area and recommend the SLR on which the agreement may be executed between the parties. The survey may be carried out in presence of both the parties and the report be submitted within 4 weeks from today. The matter will now come up on16 July.

  • Home Cable penalized for showing Media Pro continent in non-DAS areas of NCR

    Home Cable penalized for showing Media Pro continent in non-DAS areas of NCR

    NEW DELHI: The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) has imposed a penalty of Rs 25 lakh on Home Cable for violating its order of not to transmit signals Media Pro Enterprises, especially those relating to Star Sports, outside the National Capital Region (NCR) territory of Delhi.

     

    After examining certain CDs and report submitted by the Broadcasting Engineering Consultants (India) Ltd, TDSAT chairman Aftab Alam and member Kuldip Singh also said it was recalling its earlier order of 20 December, 2013 and Media Pro would be free to disconnect its signals to Home Cable in accordance with law. 

     

    The Tribunal said it was a fit case to proceed against Home Cable for violation of the undertaking given by it before the tribunal and willful failure to comply with the order, this being a case of continuing contravention of the Tribunal order. 

     

    Home Cable had initially approached TDSAT aggrieved by the disconnection order by Media Pro of 9 December, 2013 issued under clause 6.1 of the DAS Regulations alleging Home Cable was illegally and unauthorisedly carrying the channels of the respondent in an unencrypted mode in the DAS notified areas of National Capital Territory of Delhi and in areas outside the NCT of Delhi by taking the feed from the DAS notified areas, which was in violation/ non-compliance of the terms of  the MoU dated 23 October, 2012 entered between the parties.
     

     

    The Tribunal had on 20 December, 2013 directed that in case Home Cable files an undertaking before the Tribunal that it will confine its operation strictly within the DAS notified areas of NCT of Delhi and shall do the transmission/ re-transmission in digital encrypted mode, Media Pro will not discontinue the supply of its channels to Home Cable network in pursuance of the impugned Notice. It was made clear in the order that any violation of the undertaking shall make the petition liable to dismissal.

     

    It was alleged in the application by Media Pro that for the past one year or so, Home Cable had illegally been providing Media Pro’s content in brazen breach of the aforesaid undertaking. In this regard, Media Pro addressed letters in February this year to the District Collector, Gurgaon, and SSP, Gurgaon for the purpose of registration of FIRs. It was submitted on behalf of Media Pro that Home Cable was providing the content – Star Plus, Star Gold, Star Sports 4 and Star Sports 3 in Gurgaon through Sun Direct DTH boxes. The water marks clearly and conspicuously show Media Pro’s logo as well as that of Sun Direct on the screen.

     

    The BECIL report conclusively established that the system does not comply with the security provisions mandated  by the Regulations, the Tribunal said.

  • TDSAT rejects Star India’s applications against Indusind, Goldstar

    TDSAT rejects Star India’s applications against Indusind, Goldstar

    NEW DELHI: The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) has rejected four miscellaneous applications relating to five cases against it to the effect that an endorsement made by the petitioners at the end of agreements left ‘the door open to the petitioners to walk out of any clause.’

     

    Four petitions had been filed by Indusind Media and one by Goldstar Noida Network Pvt. Ltd., U.P.

     

    Star India Pvt. Ltd. Counsel Salman Khurshid said that while executing the interconnect agreement in pursuance of the order passed by the Tribunal, the petitioners made the endorsement that the execution on its behalf was “without prejudice.” He said the whole agreement was put in a state of uncertainty because of the endorsement at the bottom of the agreement.

     

    However, counsel Vandana Jaisingh for the petitioners stated that the endorsement “without prejudice” relates only to the 15 per cent increase in the subscription fee and to no other clause in the agreement, including the clauses relating to the additional areas.

     

    It was made clear in the order by which the two sides were directed to execute the agreement that the 15 per cent increase in subscription fee will be subject to the result of a petition pending before the Tribunal. In any view, therefore, the endorsement “without prejudice” is redundant, she said.

     

    TDSAT chairman Aftab Alam and member Kuldip Singh said in the order that no further directions need be passed in these applications in view of the clarification made by Jaisingh.

  • Sun to resume distribution of Ortel signals in Vishakapatnam; subject to payment clearance

    Sun to resume distribution of Ortel signals in Vishakapatnam; subject to payment clearance

    NEW DELHI: Sun Distribution Services Pvt. Ltd has been directed to resume the supply of its signals to Ortel Communications Ltd and will also execute the interconnect agreement within one week from that date.

     

    Telecom Disputes Settlement and Arbitration Tribunal (TDSAT) chairman Justice Aftab Alam and member Kuldip Singh also held that Ortel will pay to Sun the payment of Rs 33,89,910 plus Rs 4,22,976 within 24 hours.

     

    In addition to the payments, Ortel will also give to Sun the certificate showing the deduction of taxes.

     

    However, TDSAT made it clear that the payment of Rs 4,22,976 will be subject to the Tribunal’s decision on the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India’s tariff order relating to inflationary increase, which is currently pending hearing before TDSAT.

     

    Based on a table presented to the Tribunal by Ortel, the admitted dues are Rs 33,89,910 and the difference between the admitted amount and the dues claimed by the respondent is thus Rs 9,42,148.

     

    Ortel’s counsel Samir Sagar Vashistha, who presented the table, explained that this included the sum of Rs 5,18,925 as the amount of taxes deducted at source and the actual dispute is only with respect to the sum of Rs 4,22,976. 

     

    He assured that Ortel will confine its operation within the area of Vishakhapatnam.

     

    Sun counsel A.S. Dugal said the sum of Rs 4,222,976 represented the inflationary increase of 15 per cent allowed by the TRAI’s tariff order.

     

    Vashistha stated that Ortel was willing to pay the sum of Rs 33,89,910 and also give to the respondent the certificate showing deduction of taxes amounting to Rs 5,18,925. In addition, it will also pay Rs 4,22,976 subject to the Tribunal’s decision on the tariff order in question. 

     

    Dugal said the offer was quite fair and the respondent was willing to accept it.